Meeting more than one Socrates
Discover Xenophon’s Socrates and learn to compare testimonies. A way to read the sources without inventing a body of writings authored by Socrates.
An original introduction. This guide accompanies the work; it is neither the complete text nor a translation.
Understand Xenophon’s project
Memorabilia seeks to defend Socrates against the accusations brought against him. Xenophon gathers conversations and examples to demonstrate his moral usefulness. That intention shapes the scenes selected: a defensive portrait can illuminate a life while leaving certain tensions in the background. Notice the kind of evidence each episode is meant to provide.
Observe everyday philosophy
Control of desires, friendships, the organisation of life and the exercise of responsibilities play prominent roles. This Socrates often seems to offer more positive advice than the figure in dialogues ending in aporia. Compare the methods: does he supply a rule, an example or a question? The form changes what the reader learns.
Compare without reconciling everything
Place a passage from Memorabilia beside Apology or a short Platonic dialogue. Look for convergences, but preserve differences of tone and purpose. We have no text signed by Socrates that can simply settle the matter. This limit offers a lesson in historical reading: distinguish a testimony, its author and what we can reasonably conclude.
Reading Socrates begins by identifying the people who make him speak and the reasons they write.
Your turn to think.
- What might a portrait written to defend someone minimise?
- Can two different accounts be useful without both being accurate in every detail?
Your selection and progress stay in this browser.