The limits of language
Follow the numbered propositions of the Tractatus from facts and pictures to the silence of its final line.
An original introduction. This guide accompanies the work; it is neither the complete text nor a translation.
Situating the text
Drafted in notebooks kept during his service in the Austro-Hungarian army from 1914 and completed in 1918, it appeared in German in 1921 and in a bilingual edition in 1922 with an introduction by Bertrand Russell that Wittgenstein felt misread it. It was the only philosophical book he published. Readers still dispute whether its nonsense conveys ineffable insights or is meant to dissolve itself completely. In short numbered propositions, the Tractatus sets out how language can represent the world: the world is the totality of facts, a proposition is a logical picture of a possible state of affairs, and logic shows the form that language and world share. Ethics, aesthetics and the meaning of life fall outside what can be said, and the book ends by calling its own propositions nonsensical, a ladder to be thrown away once climbed.
Following the arguments
Picture theory : A proposition represents a possible state of affairs by sharing its logical form; it is true when that state of affairs obtains and false when it does not. Saying and showing : Logical form cannot be stated by a further proposition; it shows itself in the structure of the meaningful propositions we actually use. Limits of language : What lies beyond the limits of sense, including value and the mystical, is not denied but passed over in silence, as the final proposition asks.
Continuing the reading
Read the seven main propositions first, then descend into their decimal comments, keeping the preface and the closing remarks from 6.4 to 7 in view as a frame for the whole book. Drafted in notebooks kept during his service in the Austro-Hungarian army from 1914 and completed in 1918, it appeared in German in 1921 and in a bilingual edition in 1922 with an introduction by Bertrand Russell that Wittgenstein felt misread it. It was the only philosophical book he published. Readers still dispute whether its nonsense conveys ineffable insights or is meant to dissolve itself completely.
A meaningful proposition pictures a possible fact; what makes such picturing possible can only show itself.
Your turn to think.
- How does a picture share its form with what it represents?
- Why does the book call its own propositions nonsensical, and what follows for its reader?
Your selection and progress stay in this browser.