Meaning and use
Test language games, family resemblance and the remarks on rules against examples drawn from everyday speech.
An original introduction. This guide accompanies the work; it is neither the complete text nor a translation.
Situating the text
Wittgenstein worked on the book from 1936 and dated its preface January 1945, but withdrew it from publication and allowed it to appear only after his death. It was published in 1953, edited by G. E. M. Anscombe and Rush Rhees, with Anscombe’s English facing the German. The editors printed a later typescript as Part II; the 2009 revision by P. M. S. Hacker and Joachim Schulte calls it Philosophy of Psychology – A Fragment. The Investigations open with Augustine’s account of how a child learns words and use it to question the idea that every word names an object. Through language games, family resemblance and the remarks on following a rule and on a private language, Wittgenstein argues that meaning is in many cases use within shared practices, and that philosophical problems arise when language is taken out of the work it ordinarily does.
Following the arguments
Language games : Words are understood within activities such as giving orders, describing, reporting, guessing or joking; no single function defines language as a whole. Rule-following : Following a rule is a practice sustained by training and agreement in reactions, not an inner interpretation that settles every future step in advance. Private language : A language whose words referred only to one speaker’s inner sensations would lack any criterion of correct use, so that whatever seemed right would be right.
Continuing the reading
Read §§1 to 43 slowly, then the remarks on rules from §185 to §242 and on sensation from §243; test each remark against an example of your own rather than extracting theses. Wittgenstein worked on the book from 1936 and dated its preface January 1945, but withdrew it from publication and allowed it to appear only after his death. It was published in 1953, edited by G. E. M. Anscombe and Rush Rhees, with Anscombe’s English facing the German. The editors printed a later typescript as Part II; the 2009 revision by P. M. S. Hacker and Joachim Schulte calls it Philosophy of Psychology – A Fragment.
Many philosophical puzzles loosen once we describe how words are actually used instead of searching for hidden essences.
Your turn to think.
- In which language game does the word you are examining do its work?
- What makes one way of continuing a number series correct, if not an inner interpretation?
Your selection and progress stay in this browser.